Do alcoholics deserve liver transplants? - New York Daily News.
The argument that alcoholics are prone to other diseases, and therefore should be denied transplants are fallacious for several reasons. Firstly, just because alcoholics have a heightened chance to get other diseases, it doesn’t mean all alcoholics have all the listed diseases. In many cases alcoholics get successful transplants.
A liver transplant is the only known cure, yet many ALD patients are unable to get on a list for one of these donated organs. This is because transplant hospitals commonly require patients waiting for a new liver to demonstrate six months of sobriety before they’re allowed to register.
In their paper “Should Alcoholics Compete Equally for Liver Transplantation”, Alvin H. Moss and Mark Siegler seek to determine just this. Moss and Siegler argue the second view, maximum benefit, and say that alcoholics should be placed at the bottom of the transplant waiting list.
Moss and Siegler argue the second view, maximum benefit, and say that alcoholics should be placed at the bottom of the transplant waiting list. They claim that because liver transplants are a “non-renewable, absolutely scarce resource” they should go to those who have a greater chance of having a full life after receiving a new liver.
Recent evidence suggests that liver transplants can succeed in patients with alcoholic hepatitis without a mandatory six-month sobriety period.
This paper examines the criteria used to determine who may receive a liver transplant and, in particular, whether alcoholics should be allotted livers for transplant. Alcoholics tend to be given low priority status on liver transplant waiting lists or are even taken off such lists because they are considered responsible for their organ's diseased condition.
KIE In 1990, the Health Care Financing Administration recommended that Medicare coverage for liver transplantation be offered to patients with alcoholic cirrhosis who are abstinent, and that the.
Should Alcoholics Get a Liver Transplant? Joe Galati, M.D.: Whether or not alcoholic should receive a liver transplant is a tremendous debates currently in the public. Those that are against allowing alcoholics to get transplanted feel that the alcoholic patient brought the disease on upon him or herself. Why should a precious liver transplant go to somebody that was.
The liver is one of the largest and most complex organs in the body. It stores vital energy and nutrients, manufactures proteins and enzymes necessary for good health, protects the body from disease, and breaks down (or metabolizes) and helps remove harmful toxins, like alcohol, from the body.
Phil is a chronic alcoholic who as a result is suffering advanced terminal liver failure and his only lifeline is a liver transplant. However he is refused even getting onto the transplant list unless he has been totally alcohol free for over 6 months.
Maybe that liver is the only liver available at that time. Hard decisions would need to be made where only one person is chosen for a transplant, and there really is no right answer as to who that is. However, the fact that the person is an ex-alcoholic should not hinder their chances of receiving a transplant.
This should be regarded as an important part of liver transplantation for alcohol - related liver disease. Only half the units have personnel at p resent that could help fulfil this role at present. A national audit of listing and outcome would be desirable. ALCOHOL AS A CO -FACTOR.
If a liver transplant inside an alcoholic will need to be replaced after about 20 years while it could have saved another life in its entirety, then I feel obliged to say no. From an ethical viewpoint: Yes, but only if the alcoholic's need for an organ is severe, and if all other patients, who need a similar one, will sufficiently likely.
Here's an interesting question. Should alcoholics with liver failure be candidates for liver transplants, some of which will presumably paid for by health insurance or public funds? A recent article raised this controversial topic (see: Liver Transplant Can Give Some Alcoholics a Second Chance, Says French Study). Below is an.
Why do you think recovering alcoholics should be required to stay sober for six months before they can receive a liver transplant? We need to be aware of some statistics. One is that we know that.
Liver Transplants for Alcoholics: A Public Debate - Recovery First Treatment Center An alcoholic must be sober for a minimum of six months before they become eligible for a transplant. Some alcoholics don’t live long enough to meet the criteria. An alcoholic must be sober for a minimum of six months before they become eligible for a transplant.